The case of Murray Energy v. HBO and John Oliver has been adjudicated and DISMISSED by the Presiding Judge in West Virginia.
Marshall County Court Judge Jeffrey D. Cramer found
“the arguments set forth in the Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss . . . well-founded, appropriate in this matter and will grant the same.”
The Media giants had stood firmly on first amendment grounds, defending against Plaintiffs’ defamation claims on the grounds that the segment’s statements were either (a) true, or (b) jokes. Without fanfare, Judge Cramer wrote
“[t]he Court adopts, with little exception, Defendants’ arguments in support of their Motion regarding all issues . . . .”
The two-page Order dismisses the case ‘with prejudice’, extinguishing the claims as having been adjudicated and closing off any chance of the action being filed again. The losing parties, Plaintiffs Murray Energy and other coal companies, have the right to appeal within 30 days.
Meanwhile, Defendants have the honor of drafting their own victory:
“Counsel for the Defendants shall prepare and forward a proposed Order, including findings of fact and conclusions of law supporting the Court’s ruling. The same shall be forwarded within 20 days . . . .”
Here is a copy of the February 21st, 2018, Order of Court:
[pdf-embedder url=”http://lawfulmasses.com/wp-content/uploads/securepdfs/2018/02/8882620632_3048453948_10122921730001_.pdf” title=”Murray Energy v. John Oliver DISMISSED”]
For an understanding of what John Oliver and company’s winning arguments were, see Defendants’ Memorandum in Support of their Motion to Dismiss:
[pdf-embedder url=”http://lawfulmasses.com/wp-content/uploads/securepdfs/2018/02/murray-v-oliver-failure-to-state-a-claim.pdf” title=”Defendant’s Memo in Support of Dismissal”]
THANK YOU PATRONS!
Special Thanks to John from On The Branch Gaming for their $1,000 donation to help me pay for my car repair! https://youtube.com/OnTheBranchGamingLP
Support more videos here:
February Supporters and Sponsors:
John Steel, Gavin Barnard, The Godslain, Eevi, Andy, Kyle Mudrak, John H. Andersen, Verement Tayne
Git2DaChoppa, Arron Washington, Sara MacAulay, Keith Marrocco, Stephen Stair, Paul Mason, Georg Monsen, JH, Beef, Mark Randall, Dustin Rodriguez, Cindy Campbell, Pinky, Stephen Bank, Emeric Stexen, Hayden Ainger, Jasper Nabert, Christen C Cloar, Dj Gilcrease, Nate Beck, Lydia Collinson, Daniel Nichols, Jamie Sawyer, Michael Morris, Tymoteusz Paul, Richard Shotwell, Nicholas Romano, Daniel Y Ji, Justin Myers, Hannah Dernier, Paul Bible, Matthew M., Paul Bishop, etherealblah, Cameron MacFarland, Sarah Gerweck, Haris Bukic, Erik van ‘t Wout, Matthew East, Christopher Kimbrow, CheeseDeluxe, Scott R Weigle, Kelcie Hill, Noah Emmett Buckley, David Silvester, Michael Potter, Clay Chipps, DreadPirateDuo, Casey Smyth, Jonah Sokoloff, moechine, Pat Delaney, Jamie Lawson, Michael Howard, Mario Bonales, Austin Barnes, Nick Ramos, Mathew Sforcina, Michael Kenton, Euchale, Justin P, Lauren, Hugues Ross, charlieabelar, Aaron Weaver, Arya Popescu, Vaylenisme, Zach Bates, Oddport, Jack Decker, Brody Eastwood, Ian McDonald, Jenny Colby, Christopher Cookson, Marcus Agehall, Mai Vuong, Paul Schroeder, Joe Roberts, Sam Noedel, Henrik Eriksson, CowboyChemist, Sokar117, Ceryx, Jonathan Robillard, Znakemane, Michael Russell, Doug Chase, david hilton, Peter Berre Eriksen, Jon & Kanza, Amanda Gillies, TikiTDO, Patrick, Sheila Boettcher, Lorn Augier, Sean McCarthy, Arakki, Derresh, Scott, Justin Waddell, Tim Springer, Zzyzx Wolfe, Andrew Sellers, Vienticus, Matthew, Christopher Schmitt, Alisa, Brendan Horn, Camilla Sandman, Benoit Mortier, David Haig, Nathaniel Cherry, Powers Bilodeau, dead_battery, Stephen A. Wilson, Tony Cruickshank, Philip Robb, Christoph Bolliger, Michael Nelson, Georgio Mosqueda, Kirito126, Zoe, Katie Tidwell, Gregory Ford, Tron BÃ¥rdgÃ¥rd, Sancho, TwixOps, Jesse Hill, Cash Steel, Alice Shambrook, News Cartridge, Chris N, Druid, Daniel, Ian Erskine, Noelle Sorrell, Kari Sunderland, Ben Michael, BodhyOhs, Richard Jeffery, Michal PavelÄÃk, Johan, Nicholas Jarvis, Simon Dompeling, Daniel Kertesz, Norman Wanman, Jonathan Tunnell, Jason Lingle, Nolan Perez, Bryan Mitchell, jan grundey, Chris Hendrickson, Kasierith Atrovska, David Oglesby, Anders Olsaker, Rinoa Super-Genius, DreamerDon, Philip Mathews II, Marcus krefting, Kris Gilmore, Daniel NordstrÃ¶m, James, Oisin Creaner, Kevin Welsh, Bruce Fong, Andrew Spahr, Dimitrios Georgakopoulos, Michal Grycel, Kate Grycel, Jeremy Deters, Stephen Christopher, Masha Vasilchikova, Fatal Foxtrot, Alex Wheatley, Michael van der Plank, Jerry Knight, Miles Spoor, TEEKAY, Stefan Persson, Dave Vike, Edward & Hila Goikhman, Spirit Bear, Steven Hess, Darconus, Dean Herbert, Miya Graves, Kurt Mueller, Yoshiman__, Kristina Velvin, Frederick Cooper, Andrew D. Snow, Wes Morrison, Casey Kikendall, Armando Corpus, Keith Myers, Will Wagner, Jeff White, Bruce Geryk, Coleman Mavity, Michael Donnelly, Anders Lundberg, Paul Davis, HenTropy